Top Pros & Cons of Using Arbitration to Resolve Disputes

Posted by Kompass Professional Development on Jul 13, 2018, 11:07:58 AM
Kompass Professional Development

Updated November 2026

Arbitration can be used to resolve everything from personal injury cases and commercial disputes to conflicts between countries. But how does it differ from mediation and litigation? And why would clients opt for arbitration over other forms of dispute resolution?

In this post, we break down some of the most common advantages and challenges of arbitration, with the goal of helping newcomers to the field get a better sense of how this process works.

Thinking about becoming an arbitrator? Take a look at the key features of arbitration, and some of the issues you'll face helping clients settle disputes within this framework.

 

Choice: Participants Can Decide the Arbitration Structure & Process

In litigation, parties have very little say over how the process unfolds. They can't choose the judge, modify the structure of the proceedings, or decide where it will take place.

In arbitration, on the other hand, participants have a lot more choice. They decide on the arbitrator (or arbitration panel) together. They choose the place where the arbitration will take place and agree on the rules of procedure.

For example, an arbitration can play out in an informal setting, with parties seated around a table. Or it can adopt a more formal courtroom-style process, where witnesses are examined and cross-examined.

Skilled arbitrators are prepared to adapt their approach to suit the needs of each client and the nature of the dispute.

 

Expense: Arbitration Usually Costs less Than Litigation

In many cases, the streamlined nature of arbitration helps control expenses. The parties can agree to limit how much information they exchange, which can cut down on time-consuming document review.

Costs can also be more predictable. In court, delays and a drawn-out process make it hard to know how big the legal bill will get. 

 

 

Time: Arbitration is Typically Faster Than Litigation

Because parties can define the structure for arbitration and even set an end date for the process, arbitration is often faster than going to court. It's even possible to fast-track an arbitration, and the built-in flexibility helps remove much of the red tape associated with litigation.

With delays and continuations, court disputes can take months or even years to play out—whereas arbitration can be completed in a matter of weeks.

(There are some exceptions, though. Complicated disputes with multiple parties and arbitrators can be quite long and drawn out.)

 

Privacy: Arbitration is private

Have a client who doesn't want media coverage or for the details of the conflict to become publicly known? Arbitration can help. Unlike court, arbitration hearings are private, so the public can’t attend.

Where litigated disputes offer very little in the way of discretion, arbitration can be kept private and confidential. This is widely considered a major advantage of arbitration.

 

Adversarial: The Win-Lose Outcome Can Be a Problem in Some Cases

Similar to litigation, arbitration is usually an adversarial, win-lose process. The arbitrator decides the outcome. Finding a solution that works for both parties is more often associated with mediation.

So, much like litigation, there is usually a party who feels disappointed in the end, which can easily lead to a re-escalation of conflict.

Adding fuel to the fire, appeal rights are limited. In many cases, you can only appeal on a question of law, and only if the arbitration agreement allows it or a court gives permission.

In these cases, mediation may be a better fit, so both parties can walk away feeling as though they've gained something.

 

Enforcement: ARBITRATION AWARDS ARE WIDELY ENFORCEABLE

When parties go to arbitration, they also agree to respect the outcome and abide by the award. If a party refuses, the other side can ask a court to enforce it.

This is actually one of arbitration’s biggest strengths in cross-border disputes. Under the New York Convention, 172 contracting states, including Canada, agreed to recognize and enforce foreign arbitration awards, subject to limited exceptions.

 

 

Can the Informality of Arbitration Jeopardize Fairness?

This is a point of debate among legal professionals. Some say the potential informality of arbitration may actually be a disadvantage for clients, who don't end up benefiting fully from the rule of law. Others worry that arbitrators may split the difference to please both parties, rather than focusing on what is fair and just.

There are indeed some highly contested disputes that are more appropriate for litigation versus arbitration—where a formal discovery process and the rules of evidence are necessary to reach a fair outcome.

The truth is, there are pros and cons to every form of dispute resolution, including litigation, arbitration, mediation, and negotiation. Each has its own advantages and limitations.

Read more: Arbitration vs. Mediation vs. Conciliation

 

EXPLORE THE ARBITRATION CERTIFICATE FROM KOMPASS

Browse courses, learn about our online learning method, or chat live with a knowledgeable advisor. We're here to help!

Explore Accredited Arbitration Training at Kompass

 

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT THE PROS AND CONS OF ARBITRATION

Is arbitration cheaper than going to court?

Often, but not always. Arbitration can save on legal fees because it's usually faster and more streamlined. But the parties pay the arbitrator's fees and any hearing costs, which they don't pay for a judge. For small claims, court may be the cheaper option.

Can an arbitration award be enforced in another country?

In most cases, yes. Canada and 171 other countries are parties to the New York Convention, which requires courts to recognize and enforce foreign arbitration awards. A court can refuse only on limited grounds.

Does an arbitration decision set a legal precedent?

No. An arbitration award binds only the parties to that dispute. Court decisions, by contrast, are public and can guide how future cases are decided. If a party needs a public ruling on a legal issue, court may be a better choice.

When is going to court a better choice than arbitration?

Court can be a better fit when a party needs a public ruling, when the parties can't agree to arbitrate, or when the claim is small enough for small claims court. Court may also be the only option in some consumer and employment disputes, where arbitration clauses may not be enforceable.

 

Topics: arbitration